Document Type : Research Paper
Authors
1 Associate Professor, Department of Public Law, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran.
2 PhD, Department of Public Law, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Introduction and Statement of the Problem:
Historical disputes over political authority after the Prophet and the emergence of sharp divisions among Muslims, along with the Shiite position that a political ruler must be appointed by God and the minority status of this view, gave rise to an approach among Shiite jurists that was generally delegitimizing toward worldly political authority. In the presence of the Imam, Shiites considered the present Imam the only person qualified to assume political power. Given new circumstances, such an approach required reexamination during the occultation. The first changes began with modifications in juristic rulings, and with the formation of the theory of general deputization (niyābat ‘āmma), efforts were made to ease the life of Shiites; this continued until Shiite rulers came to power. With the formation of the first Shiite centers of power, the role of jurists became more pronounced. This development marks a turning point in the evolution of jurists’ political and theological theories and created a space for putting theological and juristic ideas into practice. The theory of political power in Shiism is the result of centuries of juristic intellectual struggle. The jurists’ thought can be divided into two stages:
Delegitimizing customary political power and legitimizing it. By scrutinizing the changes that have occurred in Shiite juristic rulings, its developmental trajectory is examined, and the process of transition from delegitimization to legitimization is formulated based on primary sources. The passage from a theoretical orientation centered on disinterest in customary political power and lack of a coherent theory about it toward a situation in which that power becomes a theoretical concern and object of jurists’ attention is examined under two main concepts: delegitimizing and legitimizing.
Research Background:
In previous studies, the prevailing intellectual tradition in Shiism and Shiite political jurisprudence has generally been described as the development and formation of the theory of general deputization. It has been regarded as the authentic and sole theory put forward by jurists in Shiite jurisprudence without attention to how it formed and was established or the historical context in which it emerged and spread. However, referring to jurisprudential texts compiled in early periods shows that the widespread and initially accepted historical theory was delegitimization of power; from the Middle Ages and with the rise to power of Shiite rulers, the dominant discourse shifted toward legitimizing customary political power. Understanding the theory of general deputization in its current articulation is not possible without a careful consideration of the earlier theory.
Research Objective:
This study discusses the theory of general deputization and the currently prevalent theory in Shiite political jurisprudence as the intellectual development connected to its antithetical theory—namely, the delegitimization of customary political power—as a historically prior political theory, relying on texts composed by jurists and on how it was completed and developed.
Research Method:
The present research uses a library-based method and examines books authored by Shiite jurists in historical continuity.
Conclusion:
By closely examining jurists’ theories, which were historically analyzed from the earliest authoritative jurists in Shiism to the present, it can be argued that their primary intellectual concern was preserving the identity of the Shiite sect in accordance with the governing principles of their theological and juristic beliefs. At one period, given the social circumstances and the need to preserve the communal life of Shiites, their view of political power was negative, permitting interaction between adherents of the sect and political authority only out of necessity At another period, owing to changed social conditions, jurists’ theories moved toward defining a specific political position for the jurist as an active political and legitimizing agent in social and political dimensions and as one who carries out religious duties.
Although these ideas have not always been expressed uniformly, we currently face two differing approaches: a minority and a majority approach. The minority approach believes in delegitimizing political power and limits the legitimization of it to restricted matters, viewing the jurist solely as an overseer. The majority approach, also referred to as general deputization, especially with the development and formulation of the theory of the jurist’s absolute guardianship (wilāyat-i mutlaqah al-faqīh), regards the jurist as the legitimate ruler and executor of the sect in all affairs. An idea that formed in the early period of jurisprudence, through the development of theological and juristic concepts, gradually became one of the most important political theories in Shiite political theology, managing to formulate a theory in accordance with the necessities of the lives of adherents that, for the first time, defined and preserved Shiite political and religious identity together in its present form.
One key reason for the change in juristic thought and the examination of the capacities present in hadith texts for forming elements that legitimize power is their increasing engagement with political institutions. After several centuries, the growth of the Shiite population and the establishment of political powers by them made outright denial impossible; continuing the previous approach of absolute rejection would have been self-defeating and would have created difficulties for Shiite life.
Therefore, jurists—especially after the Safavid shahs came to power—sought, by rethinking hadith texts and discovering new capacities, to provide some form of legitimation for customary power, to preserve the newly established and widespread Shiite power, and to consolidate the existence of Shiites, who until then had been struggling to assert themselves within the political community.
Keywords
(A) Persian-language Sources
- Akbari, Kamal. (2013). Political Jurisprudence and the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies. [In Persian]
- Algar, Hamid. (1990). Religion and State in Iran (A. Seri, Trans.). Tehran: Toos. [In Persian]
- Ravandi, Morteza. (2003). The Social History of Iran. Tehran: Negah Publications. [In Persian]
- Jazarī, Ibn al‑Athir. (1992). The Complete History of Islam and Iran (A. Khalili & A. Halat, Trans.). Tehran: Scientific Publications Institute. [In Persian]
- Jafariyan, Rasoul. (2002/1423 AH). Twelve Jurisprudential Treatises on Friday Prayer. Qom: Ansarian Publications. [In Persian]
- Mousavi Khomeini, Seyyed Ruhollah. (2002/1423 AH). Guardianship of the Jurist (Wilayat al‑Faqih). Tehran: Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini’s Works. [In Persian]
- Shams al‑Din, Mohammad Mahdi. (1996). The System of Government and Administration in Islam (S. M. Ayatollahi Shirazi, Trans.). Tehran: University of Tehran Press. [In Persian]
- Schuler, Bertolda. (1994). The History of Iran in the Early Islamic Centuries (4th ed., J. Aflatuni & M. Mirahmadi, Trans.). Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. [In Persian]
- Tabatabaeifar, Seyyed Mohsen. (2016). Jurisprudential Aspects of the Role of People in Government. Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]
- Tabatabaeifar, Seyyed Mohsen. (2015). The Sultanate System from the Perspective of Shiʿi Political Thought. Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]
- Feirahi, Davoud. (2007). Power, Knowledge, and Legitimacy in Islam. Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]
- McDermott, Martin. (1993). Theological Thought of Shaykh Mufid (A. Aram, Trans.). Tehran: University of Tehran Press. [In Persian]
- Mousavian, Seyyed Abolfazl. (2016). Foundations of Religious Democracy. Qom: Mofid University Press. [In Persian]
- Mirahmadi, Mansour. (2014). Salam and Deliberative Democracy. Tehran: Ney Publishing. [In Persian]
- Naʾini, Mirza Mohammad Hossein. (2014). Tanbīh al‑Ummah wa Tanzīh al‑Millah. Qom: Bustan‑e Ketab. [In Persian]
(B) Arabic-language Sources
- Ardabili, Ahmad ibn Muhammad. (1408 AH). Majmaʿ al‑Fāʾida wa al‑Burhān fī Sharḥ Irshād al‑Adhān. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Bahr al‑ʿUlūm, Muhammad ibn Muhammad Taqi. (1403 AH). Bulghat al‑Faqīh. Tehran: Maktabat al‑Sadiq Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Baghdadi, al‑Mufid, Muhammad ibn Muhammad ibn al‑Nuʿman al‑ʿAkbari. (1413 AH). Al‑Muqniʿa (by al‑Shaykh al‑Mufid). Qom: International Congress for the Millennium of al‑Shaykh al‑Mufid. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Baghdadi, al‑Mufid, Muhammad ibn Muhammad ibn al‑Nuʿman al‑ʿAkbari. (1413 AH). Nuqat al‑Iʿtiqādiyya. Qom: General Conference for al‑Shaykh al‑Mufid. [In Arabic]
- Hakim, Sayyid Mohsen Tabatabaʾi. (1416 AH). Mustamsak al‑ʿUrwa al‑Wuthqā. Qom: Dar al‑Tafsir Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Halabi, Abu al‑Salah, Taqi al‑Din ibn Najm al‑Din. (1403 AH). Al‑Kāfī fī al‑Fiqh. Isfahan: Imam Amir al‑Muʾminin Public Library. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Halabi, Ibn Abi al‑Majd, Ali ibn Hasan. (1414 AH). Ishārat al‑Sabaq ilā Maʿrifat al‑Haqq. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑Muhaqqiq, Najm al‑Din, Jaʿfar ibn Hasan. (1408 AH). Sharāʾiʿ al‑Islam fī Masāʾil al‑Ḥalāl wa al‑Ḥarām. Qom: Ismaʿiliyan Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑Muhaqqiq, Najm al‑Din, Jaʿfar ibn Hasan. (1418 AH). Al‑Mukhtasar al‑Nāfiʿ fī Fiqh al‑Imāmiyya. Qom: Al‑Maktabat al‑Diniyya Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, Fakhr al‑Muhaqqiqin, Muhammad ibn Hasan ibn Yusuf. (1387 AH). Īḍāḥ al‑Fawāʾid fī Sharḥ Mushkilāt al‑Qawāʿid. Qom: Ismaʿiliyan Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, Ibn Idris, Muhammad ibn Mansur ibn Ahmad. (1410 AH). Al‑Sarāʾir al‑Ḥāwī li‑Taḥrīr al‑Fatāwā. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, Yahya ibn Said. (1405 AH). Al‑Jāmiʿ li‑l‑Sharāʾiʿ. Qom: Sayyid al‑Shuhadāʾ Scientific Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑ʿAllāma, Hasan ibn Yusuf ibn Muṭahhar al‑Asadi. (1420 AH). Taḥrīr al‑Aḥkām al‑Sharʿiyya ʿalā Madhhab al‑Imāmiyya (modern ed.). Qom: Imam Sadiq Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑ʿAllāma, Hasan ibn Yusuf ibn Muṭahhar al‑Asadi. (n.d.). Taḥrīr al‑Aḥkām al‑Sharʿiyya ʿalā Madhhab al‑Imāmiyya (old ed.). Mashhad: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑ʿAllāma, Hasan ibn Yusuf ibn Muṭahhar al‑Asadi. (1419 AH). Nihāyat al‑Aḥkām fī Maʿrifat al‑Aḥkām. Qom: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, al‑ʿAllāma, Hasan ibn Yusuf ibn Muṭahhar al‑Asadi. (1414 AH). Tadhkirat al‑Fuquhāʾ (modern ed.). Qom: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Hilli, Muqaddad ibn ʿAbd Allah al‑Sayuri. (1425 AH). Kanz al‑ʿIrfān fī Fiqh al‑Qurʾān. Qom: Murtadha Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Khorasani (Akhund), Muhammad Kazem. (1426 AH). Kifāyat al‑Uṣūl. Qom: Islamic Publications Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Daylami, Sallar, Hamza ibn ʿAbd al‑Aziz. (1404 AH). Al‑Marāsim al‑ʿAlawiyya wa al‑Aḥkām al‑Nabawiyya. Qom: Al‑Haramein Publications. [In Arabic]
- Rahman Setayesh, Muhammad Kazem. (1425 AH). Rasāʾil fī Wilāyat al‑Faqīh. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office of the Seminary. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Sabzewari, al‑Muhaqqiq, Muhammad Baqir ibn Muhammad Muʾmin. (1423 AH). Kifāyat al‑Aḥkām. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Sabzewari, al‑Muhaqqiq, Muhammad Baqir ibn Muhammad Muʾmin. (1247 AH). Dhakhīrat al‑Maʿād fī Sharḥ al‑Irshād. Qom: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Sharif al‑Murtada, Ali ibn Husayn al‑Musawi. (1405 AH). Rasāʾil al‑Sharif al‑Murtada. Qom: Dar al‑Qurʾan al‑Karim. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Sharif al‑Murtada, Ali ibn Husayn al‑Musawi. (1387 AH). Jumal al‑ʿIlm wa al‑ʿAmal. Najaf al‑Ashraf: Matbaʿat al‑Adab. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tabrisi, Ahmad ibn Ali. (1403 AH). Al‑Iḥtijāj. Mashhad: Murtadha Publishing. [In Arabic]
- Sadr, Sayyid Muhammad Baqir. (n.d.). Khilāfat al‑Insān wa Shahādat al‑Anbiyāʾ. Tehran: Al‑Baʿtha Institute. [In Arabic]
- Sadr, Sayyid Muhammad Baqir. (1399 AH). Lamḥa Fiqhiyya Tamḥīdiyya ʿAn Mashrūʿ Dustūr al‑Jumhūriyya al‑Islāmiyya fī Īrān. Qom: Al‑Khayyam Press. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tarabulsi, Ibn al‑Bārāj, Qadi, ʿAbd al‑Aziz. (1406 AH). Al‑Muhadhdhab (by Ibn al‑Bārāj). Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tusi, Abu Jaʿfar, Muhammad ibn Hasan. (1400 AH). Al‑Nihāya fī Mujarrad al‑Fiqh wa al‑Fatāwā. Beirut: Dar al‑Kitab al‑ʿArabi. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tusi, Abu Jaʿfar, Muhammad ibn Hasan. (1387 AH). Al‑Mabsūt fī Fiqh al‑Imāmiyya. Tehran: Al‑Maktaba al‑Murtadawiyya li‑Iḥyāʾ al‑Āthār al‑Jaʿfariyya. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tusi, Abu Jaʿfar, Muhammad ibn Hasan. (1406 AH). Al‑Iqtisād fīmā Yataʿallaq bi‑l‑Iʿtiqād. Beirut: Dar al‑Adwa. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tusi, Abu Jaʿfar, Muhammad ibn Hasan. (1375 SH). Al‑Iqtisād al‑Hādī ilā Ṭarīq al‑Irshād. Tehran: Ketabkhaneh Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Tusi, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Hamza. (1408 AH). Al‑Wasīla ilā Nayl al‑Faḍīla. Qom: Ayatollah Marʿashi Najafi Library Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Muẓaffar, Muhammad Rida. (1422 AH). Uṣūl al‑Fiqh: Mabāḥith al‑Alfāẓ wa al‑Mulāzamat al‑ʿAqliyya wa Mabāḥith al‑Ḥujja wa al‑Uṣūl al‑ʿAmaliyya (A. Zarei Sabzevari, Ed.). Qom: Bustan al‑Kitab. [In Arabic]
- Attributed to Imam al‑Ridha, Ali ibn Musa. (1406 AH). Al‑Fiqh – Fiqh al‑Ridha. Mashhad: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Qatifī, Ibrahim ibn Sulayman. (1413 AH). Al‑Sirāj al‑Wahhāj. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Qummi, al‑Saduq, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Babawayh. (1413 AH). Man Lā Yaḥḍuruhu al‑Faqīh. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Qummi, al‑Saduq, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Babawayh. (1368 AH). ʿIlal al‑Sharāʾiʿ. Qom: Davari Bookstore. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Bahaʾ al‑Din Muhammad ibn Husayn & al‑Sawaji, Nizam ibn Husayn. (1429 AH). Jāmiʿ ʿAbbasi wa Takmīluhu (annotated, modern ed.). Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Shahid al‑Awwal, Muhammad ibn Makki. (1417 AH). Al‑Durūs al‑Sharʿiyya fī Fiqh al‑Imāmiyya. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Shahid al‑Awwal, Muhammad ibn Makki. (1412 AH). Al‑Bayān. Qom: Muḥaqqiq. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Shahid al‑Awwal, Muhammad ibn Makki. (1410 AH). Al‑Lumʿa al‑Dimashqiyya fī Fiqh al‑Imāmiyya. Beirut: Dar al‑Turath – al‑Dar al‑Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Shahid al‑Thani, Zayn al‑Din ibn Ali. (1413 AH). Masālik al‑Afhām ilā Tanqīḥ Sharāʾiʿ al‑Islam. Qom: Al‑Maʿarif al‑Islamiyya Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Karki, al‑Muhaqqiq al‑Thani, Ali ibn Husayn. (1414 AH). Jāmiʿ al‑Maqāṣid fī Sharḥ al‑Qawāʿid. Qom: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Karki, al‑Muhaqqiq al‑Thani, Ali ibn Husayn. (1413 AH). Risāla Qāṭiʿat al‑Lijāǧ fī Taḥqīq Ḥall al‑Kharāj. Qom: Islamic Publications Office affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom. [In Arabic]
- Al‑ʿAmili, al‑Karki, al‑Muhaqqiq al‑Thani, Ali ibn Husayn. (1409 AH). Rasāʾil al‑Muhaqqiq al‑Karki. Qom: Ayatollah Marʿashi Najafi Library & Islamic Publishing Office. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Kashani, al‑Fayd, Muhammad Mohsen ibn Shah Murtada. (n.d.). Mafātīḥ al‑Sharāʾiʿ. Qom: Ayatollah Marʿashi Najafi Library Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Kulaini, Abu Jaʿfar, Muhammad ibn Yaʿqub. (1407 AH). Al‑Kāfī (Islamic ed.). Tehran: Dar al‑Kutub al‑Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Najafi, Kashif al‑Ghitaʾ, Jaʿfar ibn Khidr al‑Maliki. (1422 AH). Kashf al‑Ghitaʾ ʿan Mubhamāt al‑Shariʿa al‑Gharraʾ (modern ed.). Qom: Islamic Propagation Office of the Seminary. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Najafi, Kashif al‑Ghitaʾ, Jaʿfar ibn Khidr al‑Maliki. (n.d.). Kashf al‑Ghitaʾ ʿan Mubhamāt al‑Shariʿa al‑Gharraʾ (old ed.). Isfahan: Mahdavi Publications. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Najafi, Ṣāḥib al‑Jawāhir, Muhammad Hasan. (1404 AH). Jawāhir al‑Kalām fī Sharḥ Sharāʾiʿ al‑Islam. Beirut: Dar Ihyaʾ al‑Turath al‑Arabi. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Naraqi, Mulla Ahmad ibn Muhammad Mahdi. (1422 AH). Rasāʾil wa Masāʾil (by al‑Naraqi). Qom: Naraqiyyin Congress of Mulla Mahdi & Mulla Ahmad. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Naraqi, Mulla Ahmad ibn Muhammad Mahdi. (1417 AH). ʿAwāʾid al‑Ayyām fī Bayān Qawāʿid al‑Aḥkām. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office of the Seminary. [In Arabic]
- Al‑Nuri, al‑Muhaddith, Mirza Husayn. (1408 AH). Mustadrak al‑Wasāʾil wa Mustanbat al‑Masāʾil. Beirut: Al‑al‑Bayt Institute. [In Arabic]
)