Document Type : Research Paper
Authors
1 Associate Professor, Department of History, Institute of Humanities & Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran
2 PhD Student, Department of Revolutionary History, Research Institute of Imam Khomeini and the Islamic Revolution, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
During the constitutional period changes, a new force emerged that and played an important role in the awakening of the people, familiarization with the West, and the publishing of the press, and also thought for a way out of the upcoming deadlocks. Iranian intellectuals came to understand Iran's backwardness through familiarity with the ideas of the new world, and by proposing and publishing new issues in Iranian society, they established different poles of thought that led to the mixing and even opposition of tradition and modernity. The epistemology of the reforms and the explanation of this new reading from thought to the fulfillment of an important precondition is stopped, and that is the knowledge of intellectuals and the fundamental components of their thought. This research, with a thought-oriented approach and documentary content analysis method, deals with the purposeful rereading of the works of Afrasiab Azad, the founder of Hezb Khuda and a traditionalist intellectual of the constitutional and Pahlavi periods, and by evaluating it through the logic of Skinner's contextual approach, In search of an answer to this central question, how is the position of nationalism in the works of Afrasiab Azad and its metamorphosis compared to his contemporaries and contemporaries, and how does this flow contribute to the establishment of the Pahlavi government? Free thoughts are evaluated in the context of the modernist thought of contemporary thinkers.
The documents of Afrasiab Azad are available in the sources of purchase documents and in the form of about a thousand files in the repository of documents and national archives. A small number of documents attributed to Afrasiab Azad are available in the Library of the Islamic Council and the Astan Quds Razavi Document Center and have been indexed. An autopsy of a political gathering related to the bread riot in December 1942/Azar 1321 in Tehran has quoted an article about Afrasiab Azad's speech in this context. He has also mentioned the effect of modernization and de-religion in the chapter of westernized plays in relation to the conditions of this art in the first Pahlavi period and the important role of Afrasiab Azad as one of the initiators of the play. The purpose of this study is to put Azad's key concepts in the cultural and discourse contexts from which they were formed with Skinner's method, so that the advantage and validity of his thought can be put to the test. The aim of Skinner's methodology is to enable us to recover the historical identity and genealogy of each such intellectual history text. The guide to the content analysis of the data in this research based on this approach is, on the one hand, the internal logic of the intellectuals' thought system as a whole and a text, and on the other hand, measuring it with the external logic and comparing it with contemporary publications and press - including the magazine Iranshahr, Kaveh and Aindeh- will take place and the focal point is to pay attention to the recognition of opinions and goals, ideas and the thought system of Afrasiab Azad.
The findings of the research aim to prove the hypothesis that the association of intellectuals from the intellectual spectrum of Afrasiab Azad led to the expansion of the acceptance of the discourse of authoritarian nationalism and the theorization of the legitimacy of the first Pahlavi government. With the reduction of modern components in the eyes of Azad in the atmosphere of political and intellectual obstruction of the Reza Shahi era, his influential social and political positions declined. In his works and publications, Afrasiab Azad was introduced as an orator, a freedom-seeker and a modernist of the post-constitutional era, who was later introduced as a writer, lawyer and playwright of the political and social genre. He used the ideas of modernism in his opinions to seek transformation along with the tradition and he believed in a form of moderate or reductionist modernism, which at the same time accepted the new concepts of antiquity and nationalism, and religion as well. He saw the base of social mobility and ethnic solidarity in the special political and social conditions of the post-constitutional period. This approach was interpreted and propagated in the service of authoritarian nationalism at the level of the government superstructure and the national unity of ethnicities and religions at the level of the people and the subalterns in order to gain legitimacy. Gradually, the modern ideas were transformed in his opinions and works and with the establishment of Pahlavi I, he only focused on describing and theorizing the existing conditions and the failure of the primary elements. The reduction and transformation of these ideas and accompanying the first Pahlavi government by Afrasiab Azad during the political and intellectual blockage of the Reza Shahi era, turned him into a messenger of the government's official discourse and led to the loss of his influential social and political base and the decline of his role. In the society of writers, a new idea was created.
Keywords
Main Subjects
- Publication system of the National Library of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Sena), Azad Letter, 1st year, 1st issue. [In Persian]
- Publication system of the National Library of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Sena), Azad Letter, first year, second issue. [In Persian]
- Publication system of the National Library of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Sena), Azad Letter, 1st year, 3rd issue. [In Persian]
- Publication system of the National Library of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Sena), Azad Letter, 1st year, 4th issue. [In Persian]
- Publication system of the National Library of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Sena), Azad Letter, 1326 Shamsi, special issue. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32915. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32909. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32904. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32910. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 32302/999. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32634. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 32347/999. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 32571/999. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32853. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32889. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32273. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/33813. [In Persian]
- National Library and Documents Organization of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/33477. [In Persian]
- Organization of Documents and National Library of Iran (SAKMA), retrieval number 999/32639. [In Persian]
- Organization of Libraries, Museums and Documents Center of Astan Quds Razavi (Sakmaq), document number: 130942. [In Persian]
- Library, Museum and Records Center of the Islamic Council (Kemam), Nameh Azadiyan, 1333 AH: 1178762. [In Persian]
- Taghi-zadeh, Seyyed Hasan. (1340. AH). "Political reforms and urgent reforms". Kaveh, number 1. [In Persian]
- ------------- (1339. AH). "Tips and Considerations". Kaveh, number 4. [In Persian]
- Abrahamian, Yervand. (1389). Iran between two revolutions. Translated by Ahmed Gol-Mohammadi and Mohammad Ebrahim Fattahi-Valilai, Tehran: Ni. [In Persian]
- Akhundzadeh, Mirza Fateh Ali. (1349). Parables. Try it, Mirza Jafar Qaradaghi. Tehran: Andisheh. [In Persian]
- Adamiat, Fereydon. (1357). Social thought in Iran's constitutional movement. Tehran: Payam. [In Persian]
- ----------.(1340). The idea of freedom and the introduction of the constitutional movement. Tehran: Sokhn. [In Persian]
- Afshar, Mahmoud. (1306). "Political dangers" of the Ayande. C2. Number 11. March. [In Persian]
- --------- (1304). "Introduction",The Ayande. First year, first issue. [In Persian]
- Selective, rare. (1373). "Namah Farangistan and the problem of authoritarian modernization in Iran". Negah No, No. 21. [In Persian]
- Ohadi, Parvin Dokht and Haji Rajabali, Kazem. (2014). "Discourse formation in the cultural policy of the first Pahlavi" Political Quarterly, Volume 45, Number 4. turn of winter pp. 876-859. [In Persian]
- Tully, James. (2004). "Skinner's methodology in the analysis of political thought". Translated by Gholamreza and Behruzlek. Bagher al Uloom University (AS). The turn of winter, number 28, pp. 57 to 84. [In Persian]
- Jabarlovi-Shabstri, Bahram and Nozaddizji, Nazila. (1389). "Press and journalism during the constitutional revolution and its effect on the style of writing". Journal of political and economic information. No. 278-277. pp. 261-252. [In Persian]
- Hatami, Amirhossein. (2018). "The Application of Skinner's Methodology in the Interpretation of Historiographical Texts and the History of Iranian-Islamic Thought" Quarterly Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in Humanities, No. 12, pp. 29-54. [In Persian]
- Dashti, Ali. (1340. AH). "The government or the nation, which is to blame?" Shafaq Sorkh Number 13, the month of Sha'ban. [In Persian]
- Rezai-Panah, Amir and Izadi, Rajab. (2012). "Finding the roots of the first Pahlavi discourse in the opinions of the modernists of the constitutional era". Historical essays. Research Institute of Human Sciences and Cultural Studies, 4th year, 2nd issue, pp. 35-68. [In Persian]
- Roshan, Amir. (2008). "Quentin Skinner and intentionalist hermeneutics in political thought". Political and international approach. Number 14. The turn of summer. No. 14, pp. 11-35. [In Persian]
- Rahbari, Mehdi. (2006). "Iranian modernists and modernism in the constitutional era. Investigating the origins of intellectual conflict in modern Iran". National Studies Quarterly. eighth year No. 4. pp. 55-77. [In Persian]
- Zahedi, Mohammad Javad and Heydarpour, Mohammad. (2007). "Sociology of Isolation of Intellectuals. (Criticism of intellectuals' actions during the constitutional era until the end of Pahlavi's first reign)". Iranian Journal of Sociology. 9th period. Number 1 and 2. pp. 127-164. [In Persian]
- Samaran, Charles. (1370). Research methods in history. (Abulqasem Baignah and Mehdi Alaei and others). Volume 2, Chapter 1, Mashhad: Astan Quds. [In Persian]
- Sadat's Sarparast, Seyed Ebrahim. (2014). "Developments in Iranian intellectuals' understanding of the tradition of crisis, tradition and intellectual self-awareness". Strategic Policy Research Quarterly, third year. Number 11. The turn of winter. 31-56. [In Persian]
- Shiri, Tahmworth and Azimi, Neda. (2016) "Comparative study of qualitative content analysis and hermeneutic method". Sociological studies. Fourth period, number 15, pp. 79-99. [In Persian]
- Salah, Mehdi and others. (2018). "Modernism in the thought of Mohammad Baqer Mirza Khosravi of Kermanshahi. Modernity, literature and politics", historical studies of Iran and Islam. Number 24. The turn of spring and summer. pp. 179-210. [In Persian]
- Ghani, Cyrus. (1377). Iran: the rise of Reza Khan, the rise of the Qajar and the role of the English. (Hasan Kamshad). Tehran: Nilufar Publications. [In Persian]
- Frankford, Chava and Nechmias, David. (2010). Research methods in social sciences, (Fazel Larjani and Reza Fazeli). Ch1. Tehran: Soroush Publishing. [In Persian]
- Ghayseri, Nouraleh. (2008). Elites and the evolution of political culture in Iran during the Qajar period. Tehran: Publishing Center of Islamic Revolution Documents. [In Persian]
- Kazem-zadeh Iranshahr, Hossein. (1292). "Knowledge and education of Iran". Iranshahr. Second year number 4. [In Persian]
- Kazem-zadeh Iranshahr, Hossein. (1292). "Nationality and national spirit of Iran". Iranshahr. Second year number 4. [In Persian]
- Maddpour, Mohammad. (1373). Modernization and secularization. Tehran: Shahid University Press. [In Persian]
- Moazampour, Ismail. (1383). Criticism of modernist nationalism in the era of Reza Shah. Tehran: Islamic Revolution Documentation Center. [In Persian]
- McFarland, Stephen. (2004). "An autopsy of a political gathering in Iran: the bread riot in Azar 1321 in Tehran" Contemporary History Quarterly. No. 31, pp. 101-82. [In Persian]
- Malekpur, Jamshid. (1363). Dramatic literature in Iran. C1. Tehran: Tos publishing house.
- Mehdipour, Farshad. (2014). "Typology of intellectual-cultural trends in contemporary Iran". Religion and Cultural Policy Quarterly. Second Issue. pp. 7-30. [In Persian]
- Yadegari, Samaneh and others. (2015). "Comparative study of political-literary works of constitutional intellectuals with the first Pahlavi era (case study of Kasravi and Akhundzadeh)". The paper of the international research conference in science and technology. [In Persian]